
By Andy G
On January 29, 2025, YouTube terminated the account of Carl Zha, the host of the Silk and Steel podcast, which focused on “all things China: history, culture and politics.” At time of writing, it does not appear that any of his videos appear on any English language platform, only bilibili.com, a Chinese language website.
It was only by chance that I downloaded six videos from the channel that focused on the RedNote phenomenon, otherwise this article and accompanying video would probably not exist.
What is the RedNote Phenomenon and how did it start?
In 2020, Donald Trump announced that TikTok, an app wildly popular with youth, would be banned if it didn’t part ways with its Chinese owner, ByteDance. This call came after “national-security concerns” were raised that the video-hosting service was in fact a Communist Party of China propaganda tool—one of the so-called “magic weapons” wielded by the CPC for global influence.
ByteDance announced a sale, paused the sale, cancelled the sale, and then Joe Biden revoked Trump’s ban in June 2021. Scare-mongering articles continued to be written, culminating in Biden signing a new bill to ban TikTok in April 2024. The bill was designed to force ByteDance to sell the app to a U.S. company within a year or face a national ban.
As of 2025, TikTok has up to 138 million monthly U.S. users, 41% of whom are between the ages of 16 and 24. Among these TikTok users, 90% said they used the app daily. The share of U.S. adults who regularly get news from TikTok hit 14% in 2023. By July 2023, TikTok had become the primary news source for British teenagers on social media.
After spending millions of US dollars lobbying against the legislation,ByteDance made a final legal bid, hoping that the proposed ban might constitute a violation of TikTok’s First Amendment rights. But the Supreme Court rejected that argument, time ran out, and TikTok finally went offline—before abruptly returning. Following a phone call with Xi Jinping, president of the People’s Republic of China, during which TikTok was apparently discussed, Trump has directed the Department of Justice not to enforce the ban for 75 days.
Things become interesting
In the leadup to the ban on January 19, TikTok users began flocking to a rival app, an app that initially was not designed to cater for English-language users. As one ‘TikTok Refugee’ put it in a video message to Mark Zuckerberg: “Do you know how insufferable you have to be for TikTok to get banned in the U.S. and instead of everyone going to Meta, going to your app that you own, they would rather use an app in a language they can’t understand?”
The app they are all migrating to is commonly known as RedNote, real name “Xiaohongshu,” for which the literal translation is “Little Red Book”. Sorry Lefties, this isn’t a reference to Mao’s Quotations from Chairman Mao Tse-tung, the literal translation for that usage is “Red Treasure Book”.
Xiaohongshu was founded in 2013 as an online tour guide for Chinese shoppers, providing a platform for users to review products and share their shopping experiences with the community. Due to large investment from Alibaba Group, Tencent, and Sequoia China, the app had managed to reach a user base of 300 million by the end of 2024.
RedNote is not the Chinese version of TikTok, a common misconception among new users. The parent company of TikTok, ByteDance, runs two apps: TikTok for the international audience, and Douyin for the Chinese domestic audience.
The reason users couldn’t flock to ‘Chinese TikTok’ is that not only is the app not available on App store for you to download, but even if you got your hands on an APK for your Android phone, you still need a phone number from mainland China in order to register and participate.
RedNote is a rival social media platform to ByteDance’s TikTok, the main difference being that the user base is not separated and the app is available for download in the U.S. and around the world. Once you sign up with your local phone number, it immediately places you in the same pool as 300 million Chinese users.

The trickle becomes a flood
After the impending ban on TikTok became mainstream news, the trickle of TikTok users migrating to RedNote soon became a flood, helped along by viral videos that were starting to show the real life of ordinary Chinese people. In only two days, an estimated 700,000 people had already signed on, with this number already over one million as of writing.
The day it became a flood was very noticeable due to the time difference. Users in the United States began posting lots of videos while most of the user base in China were sleeping. Examples include comments like, “hey there Americans, I’m so proud of us for all being over here right now, this is so ridiculous!” and videos showing people expressing glee and laughing over the app going to the number one spot in the app store.
When the Chinese users on the platform woke up the morning after this all started, they were surprised and bewildered at all the new refugees from TikTok. However, the overwhelming response was one of curiosity, friendliness, and a willingness to help new users navigate the system.
The hashtag “TikTok Refugee” was viewed 100 million times by Chinese users in just one week, according to Zha. Some of the comments:
“It’s like magic, it’s really surprising that today there are so many foreigners (laughs), that you guys are TikTok refugees, you make me really happy!”
“I’m going to start making videos today about learning some Chinese keywords so you can use the platform at lot easier (and have) a way better time on RedNote”
“I feel so happy and I’m really touched seeing all you guys are here because I feel the wall built by politicians between us are starting to break down and this reminds me (of) the quotes carved on Tianamen Square… the second one is ‘long live the great unity of people from the world’, and the great unity might really happen like this seems like a dream is going to come true.”
As Carl Zhu says at this point of the story, “the result I must say is amazing… I never expected in 2025 the Americans would find their way around the Great Firewall and now the internet of the world is united once again, and this was all brought on by a stupid American government policy that will have very interesting implications going forward.”
Zhu continues: “after one week of amazing Sino-American cultural exchange, the exchange is entering into a dangerous phase, now they’re comparing their medical bills and grocery expenses!”

Americans and Chinese people exchange stories
Now the exchanges are about comparing food prices in grocery stores, talking about the cost of ambulance rides, discussing ideas of freedom, comparing tax bills, and all the other little aspects of living that ordinary people have to worry about.
“People all over the world are clowning us, no wonder America been trying to keep us sheltered, you see the architecture of China’s buildings? Look how their cities look… we pay taxes why don’t our shit look like that? Why is the whole world saying that we’re just a third world country with a Gucci belt?”
Some of the more popular videos are ones that show users the insides of their houses, while others detail trips to the food halls and communal eating places. And by detail, I mean they helpfully show the prices in Yuan and what the comparable cost is in the USA.
The political level of the comments varies significantly, and it is not just lefties making them. For example, one user shows a screenshot of a news story with the headline “Blinken blames TikTok and social media for disrupting Israel’s narrative of war in Gaza” and makes the comment “…even though they said the quiet part out loud when it came to an interview in which they directly stated this was to limit Palestinian content.”
Another makes the salient point that instead of doing something about the actual genocide of Palestinians that was being live-streamed on Tiktok, American politicians moved to ban the platform that their citizens were using to complain about the genocide.

Americans in disbelief
But the best exchanges come from those totally shocked by what they saw and experienced. In some ways, these are more powerful than the ones of people making excellent political points. It’s all in the emotional tone, the sense of anger, frustration, disbelief all rolled into one, that this simple truth had deliberately been kept from them all these years:
“I’ve reached the part where I’m filled with impotent rage… that white hot, I need to sink my teeth into something and scream, kind of rage, because what do you mean that it never had to be this hard for us… that people in China work one job and they don’t even work 40 hours and they can easily afford their life and then I’m over here working 60 hours per week, just me as a single parent to barely make ends meet and I’m penny pinching every single second… and you mean to tell me that it didn’t have to be like this?”
There is hope
Possibly the best outcome of the RedNote phenomenon is the recognition, by so many people on the platform who have posted after having experienced it for themselves, that this event could open up a new age of dialogue and communication between two historically partitioned off peoples.
“I’m not being dramatic here but this app is going to change the world, hear me out here… this is the first app of its kind to connect Chinese people with Western people. For the first time ever, we are communicating, we are sharing our world… our cultures… our thoughts, where we come from, how things are… it’s incredible… finally for the first time in a long time, I’m so excited and I have hope for us!”
Zhu ends, what possibly was his last video before YouTube scrubbed his videos off the internet, with the news that the People’s Daily, the official newspaper of the Central Committee of the Chinese Communist Party, had made a commentary about the influx of American TikTok refugees onto RedNote. This was what it said in translation:
“President Xi says that the hope for US-China relations lies with the peoples. In the age of globalization and the internet, our community of shared destiny will only become closer. Rather than call them ‘refugees’, let’s call them ‘villagers of village Earth’ who have found a new home.”
Indeed.
Below is the supercut of six videos by Carl Zhu that tells the story of the RedNote Phenomenon:

Leave a Reply