What led to the fall of the Syrian government?

A portrait of Syrian President Bashar Assad is pictured with its frame broken, in a Syrian regime Political Security Branch facility on the outskirts of the central city of Hama, following the capture of the area by anti-government forces (Dec. 7, 2024). Photo: OMAR HAJ KADOUR/AFP VIA GETTY IMAGES

By Andrew Martin

The rule of Bashar al-Assad came to a dramatic end at the beginning of December. Assad’s government, a dynastic rule that lasted for 54 years, collapsed during a major offensive by opposition forces. With little centralised resistance by the Syrian Armed Forces, Turkish backed militias, the Syrian National Army (SNA) and Hay’at Tahrir al-Sham (HTS) toppled the government, seizing government buildings and critical infrastructure. Their flag of resistance was unfurled in the city.

The opposition push was fast. The onslaught of ten days brought to a close thirteen years of war that had already been preceded by years of sanctions and social turmoil.

The SNA, estimated to number between 25,000 and 70,000 fighters, consolidated other rebel factions, including what was left of the Free Syrian Army (FSA).

The actions of the SNA were closely coordinated with the HTS, a coalition of northern Syria-based Sunni Islamist insurgent groups that evolved from Jabhat al-Nusrah, or “Nusrah Front,” al-Qa’ida’s former branch in Syria. It is a sectarian split from ISIS. Due to strategic disagreements, Nusrah Front leader Abu Muhammad al-Jawlani broke with al-Qa‘ida in 2016. His image has been sanitised as the objectives of his group meet those of U.S imperialism.

The seizure of power coincided with 480 air strikes by Israel, the biggest airstrike operation in Israel’s history, which hit all major military infrastructure, including airports and all of Syria’s naval facilities.

The background and context of the civil war in Syria will show why the left should not be supporting the victory of opposition forces that have come to power. Their rise to power is not the result of “mass politics” or “popular power” asserting itself – rather it is the result of imperialist meddling.

Economic Collapse

Those who thought an Islamic state formed with the backing of U.S. imperialism might provide a measure of welfare for the people of Syria are hopelessly misguided and deceived.

One of the government’s first pronouncements was to adopt a free-market economy and integrate Syria into the global economy. Bassel Hamwi, head of the Damascus Chambers of Commerce, told Reuters that ” it will be a free-market system based on competition.” One can only assume that Syria’s oil and gas reserves will be liberalised in the interests of U.S. imperialism and all the last vestiges of state protection will be removed.

Syria was already well down the road to becoming a neo-liberal economy, but it wasn’t always so.

Led by General Salah Jadid, the military coup of 1966 elevated to power the most left-wing section of the Ba-ath party in Syria. Jadid established the most radical administration in modern Syria’s history. The Ba-ath party claimed to be leading the country to unity, freedom and socialism. It confiscated the properties of landowners and businesses. It rapidly developed the economy through central planning.

The government developed close ties with the Soviet Union and relied heavily on its aid, particularly military assistance and equipment.

Hadid had a vision of socialist development, but he made the fatal mistake of not being attentive to military power. Hafez al-Assad, charged with the Ministry of Defence had personal ambitions of power that clashed with Jadid’s vision. Assad became known as “Syria’s Suharto” among Jadid’s faction in reference to the bloody coup that overthrew Sukarno’s leftist regime in Indonesia. Bashar al-Assad sought to liberalise the economy following his assumption of power in 2000. The reforms inevitably raised inequality without fixing Syria’s underlying economic problems and were a departure from the socialist measures the Ba-ath party introduced in the late 1960s and early 1970s. By the early 1990s agriculture was controlled by 90% of the private sector sector.

Agriculture and oil accounted for 50% of GDP, but a series of severe droughts, climatic changes, soil degradation and a drop in the price of oil following the GFC weakened the economy. This led to a severe decline in agricultural production, which led to migration to urban centres where jobs were scarce.

These factors fuelled the deterioration of social conditions that gave rise to civil war. The sanctions applied to Syria were crippling. Even Australia situated some 12,000 km away, meddled in the conflict. In 2012, at the direction of the then Foreign Minister Bob Carr, the government applied sanctions blocking trade and investment in oil, petroleum, financial services, telecommunications and precious metals.

The hyperinflation that followed ruined Syria’s economy. The losses are so vast that they are virtually incalculable. In March 2015, the Syrian Center for Policy Research reported that nearly three million Syrians had lost their jobs due to the civil war, cutting off the primary source of income for over 12 million people. Unemployment rates rose sharply, increasing from 14.9% in 2011 to 57.7% by the end of 2014. And yet the war was to rage for ten more years. It was enormously destructive.

A UN-backed report released in 2015 revealed that in its first four years, the war had plunged 80 per cent of Syrian people into poverty, reducing life expectancy by 20 years and leading to massive economic losses estimated at over $200bn. Syria has one of the largest refugee populations in the world, second only to Palestine, with 3.5 million fleeing to other countries. By 2024, that number reached 6.7 million. The conflict has now dislocated at least 13 million.

A Dirty Proxy War

The civil war was not simply a result of mistakes and bad decisions made by Assad, however inept he may have been as a ruler. Syria, a site of many ancient trade routes, has been subject to the whims of colonial and imperialist powers since the collapse of the Ottoman Empire. It is strategically important in any global power play.

Syria sits at the intersection of the Middle East, connecting Asia, Europe, and Africa. It is a vital hub for trade, transportation and military access. It provides an ideal connection for oil and natural gas pipelines linking the Middle East to Europe.

Syria did not exist as a state 100 years ago (nor did Lebanon, Iraq or Israel). The British and French divided the Ottoman Empire between them – Syria was never designed to have popular sovereignty.

It is ethnically and religiously diverse – and these divisions have been manipulated and cultivated by imperialist interests. The country is home to a mix of ethnic groups, including Arabs, Kurds, Assyrians, Turkmen, Circassians, and Armenians, alongside religious communities such as Sunni Muslims, Alawites, Christians, Druze, Yazidi and others. This diversity has historically been a source of both richness and tension.

Tribal law, based on traditions and honour codes, was not abolished until 1956. The Ba’ath Party, especially under Hafez al-Assad, Bashar al-Assad’s father and predecessor, sought to reduce the power of tribal leaders by promoting centralised governance. However, the regime also co-opted tribal leaders when it was politically advantageous.

In the civil war, Turkey was able to exploit tribal differences. It supported the Jaysh al-Asha’ir (Tribal Army), a coalition of tribes to fight against the Kurdish-led SDF. It aligned with the Al-Muwali tribe in northern Syria, primarily in the Idlib and Hama regions. These alliances and coalitions were critical in Turkey’s Operation Euphrates Shield in 2016 and Operation Peace Spring 2019.

Under President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan, Turkey has sought to revive its historical role as a significant power in the Middle East, often called “neo-Ottomanism.” Once part of the Ottoman Empire, Syria is seen as a natural sphere of influence. Erdoğan uses domination in Syria to rally nationalist support domestically. Military interventions and control over border areas are often framed as defending Turkey’s sovereignty and security.

Elected at the height of the civil war, Recep Tayyip Erdoğan has sought to dominate Syria to suppress Kurdish autonomy. Turkey fears that an independent or semi-autonomous Kurdish statelet in Syria could inspire similar aspirations among its own Kurdish population in southeastern Turkey.

At the onset of the conflict, Turkey requested NATO get involved and was the most vocal in calling for a No-Fly-Zone. NATO’s member states, led by the U.S., are engaged in airstrikes and special forces deployments. However, Turkey’s hostility toward Kurdish forces (e.g., YPG, a key U.S. ally in the fight against ISIS) created tensions within NATO. The priorities of NATO eventually diverged from countering ISIS to containing Russia.

The mercenaries who seized power used military equipment directly supplied by Turkey. With the aid of U.S. bombing, the militias were able to capture 1/3 of Syria’s territory in the north, which contained the oil—and resource-rich areas and its most prosperous agricultural regions.

It’s important to note that many of the fighters in this insurgency are not even Syrian. Many come from China (Uyghur extremists) or former regions of the Soviet Union such as Chechnya and Uzbekistan. This motley resistance is united in their vision for an Islamic state.

Joe Biden took credit for the opposition’s victory: “Our approach has shifted the balance of power in the Middle East.” Under Obama, the U.S first intervened in Syria via CIA operations in 2013 and later took over large swathes of land to fight the Islamic State group.

The CIA operation, known as “Timber Sycamore,” was a classified arms supply and training operation supported by Saudi Arabia. Initially, Obama rejected the idea, raised by then-CIA director David Petraeus, but later agreed due to lobbying by Netanyahu. It was one of the costliest CIA operations in history.

Although precise figures remain classified, it is estimated that rebel groups received $500 million to $1 billion a year at the peak of CIA intervention. This included light arms, psyops, ammunition, anti-tank weapons, and logistical aid.

The Syrian government countered the operation with Russia’s aid, retaking Aleppo, the main rebel stronghold, in 2017. Russia supplied Syria with a wide range of military hardware, including tanks, fighter jets, helicopters, and air defence systems (e.g., artillery and small arms). Russian military advisers were critical in retaking Aleppo using strategies that had proved successful in Georgia. However, they did not supply large amounts of ground forces (the West consistently overstated Russian support).

Although Aleppo (and Homs and Hama) was rewon, this was perhaps the most gruelling and brutal part of the war, with many casualties. According to some sources, the overall death toll in Aleppo during the war reached over 31,000, which includes fighters and civilians. Neither could the government hold onto Aleppo for long.

The Invasion of Lebanon Turned the Tide

Israel has attacked Syria many times since the Yom Kippur War in 1973. Since the onset of the Israel’s attack on Gaza in 2023, Israeli strikes in Syria have grew more frequent and increased in intensity through 2024.

Hezbollah’s military assistance to the Assad government was critical for its survival. They were quick to offer support. In 2012, Hezbollah fighters crossed the border from Lebanon and seized control of eight villages in Syria’s Al-Qusayr District. Hezbollah’s loyalist militias were critical in the operations to take back Aleppo, where they committed some 2000 fighters.

Their experience fighting in urban environments proved particularly valuable, and their combined efforts with the Syrian Armed Forces repelled the rebels.

The opposition forces regrouped and concentrated their attacks in nearby Idlib and nearby provinces, slowly wearing down military supply lines. The invasion of Lebanon meant many of Hezbollah’s fighters returned to defend their homeland.

In November 2024, heavy fighting reignited as Tahrir al-Sham, supported by allied groups in the Turkish-backed Syrian National Army, launched a major offensive in the northwest, resulting in the capture of Aleppo, Hama, and Homs. Meanwhile, southern rebels who had earlier reconciled with the government initiated their own offensive, taking control of Daraa and Suwayda. Simultaneously, the Syrian Free Army advanced on Palmyra, while the Syrian Democratic Forces launched an offensive in Deir ez-Zor.

This attack’s level of ferocity and coordination was qualitatively larger than any other that preceded it.

These losses and the cumulative impact of sanctions demoralised those who supported Assad and his armed forces. In the last days of the regime, there is no doubt that the people of Syria felt abandoned. The insurgency’s rapid advance came as a surprise. News reports stated that rebel victories were fake news.

By December 8, rebel forces had successfully seized the capital, Damascus.

The Kurdish Question

The question of democratic rights for minorities, in particular the Kurds, will not be resolved by this new regime. HTS is supported by Turkey, whose influence over Syria’s new rulers will undermine any aspirations for Kurdish independence. The Kurds are one of the world’s largest ethnic groups without a state. Although their leaders desire some sort of sovereignty, a Kurdish state or even an autonomous zone is not a viable possibility, given that the majority of the population in northeast Syria are Arabic. Further, the Kurdish towns and villages in this region are not even connected to each other.

The reality of this “new” Syria is that it remains territorially fractured. The HTS has tried (unsuccessfully) to dissolve all the rebel factions and unite them in a new Syria army. The U.S backed SDF controls a third of Syria’s territory. The SDF is essentially a coalition of Kurdish militia that has been used by the U.S to combat ISIS. They are unlikely to accept rule by a government based on Islamic extremism.

The decision to arm the Syrian branch of the Kurdistan Workers Party (PKK) by the U.S has no doubt damaged its relations with Turkey. According to the former U.S ambassador to Turkey, “Because of the huge role the PKK has played since I was first in Turkey in 1984, the Turks can never formally accept what the U.S. is doing with the SDF.” Yet these NATO members retain a rapprochement with each other for other geo-political purposes; namely the containment of Russia. Thus the U.S, having used the Kurds to defeat ISIS, will now most likely abandon them to their fate.

The Day After is Going to be Uglier

There are many reasons why the left, ever myopic, should not be supporting or celebrating the victory of the opposition forces in Syria, however brutal the Assad government was. It takes no moral courage to condemn Assad’s rule when the most significant imperialist force in all history was determined to destroy it. The ultimate aim was to destroy the Syrian state and the sovereignty of its people, not to bring liberation.

The insurgency has taken the form of many “colour revolutions” before it. We have seen similar scenes in Libya; the consequences are disastrous. To think that a rebranded version of Al Nusra, the HTS, will provide liberation is the peak of delusion and denial of the fundamental forces at play. The images of people being freed from prison cannot cover the fact that the new Syrian state will be a vassal of U.S. imperialism.

The fall of the Assad government weakens an axis of resistance that was supplying material aid to Hamas in Palestine and Hezbollah in Lebanon. The Syrian people will lose more territory to Israel, which lost no time in creating a “buffer zone” with Israeli soldiers evicting people from their homes in the border regions. The fall of the Assad government is a big boost to the settler movement in Israel, whose politicians are saying they will not return the territories.

Netanyahu declared on X that the collapse of the Assad government was a direct result of Israel’s forceful action against Hezbollah and Iran. The timing of the offensive was no coincidence.

Lebanese American journalist Rania Khalek wrote on December 5, “There is a feeling that all the forces against Syria – Turkey, the US, Israel, etc – have joined forces to attack the resistance axis at one of its weakest moments, taking advantage of the last year plus of genocide in Gaza, destruction in Lebanon and Russia being bogged down in Ukraine. All this while U.S. sanctions and bad governance hollowed out what was left of the Syrian state and its remaining institutions. Everyone fears even darker days ahead.”

Author

Leave a Reply