By Andrew Martin
At the May, 2022 federal election, the Australian Labor Party (ALP) promised a National Greenhouse Gas Emissions Reduction Target of 43% by 2030 and net zero by 2050. Climate change was one of the issues that defined the December 2021 election and Prime minister Anthony Albanese has promised to turn Australia into a “renewable energy superpower” and end the “climate wars”. The Labor party claims: “Creating jobs, cutting power bills and reducing emissions by boosting renewable energy are at the centre of Labor’s Powering Australia plan. This plan will bring cheaper renewable energy to Australian homes and businesses.”
The ALP Climate Change Bill passed both houses in September 2022. As per their election promise the Bill aims to legislate Australia’s greenhouse gas emission reduction targets (of 43% reduction against a 2005 baseline by 2030 and net zero emissions by 2050). The Bill will require an annual Ministerial statement to Parliament on progress towards achievement of these targets.
But there is an irreconcilable contradiction facing the ALP: they also continue to support and subsidise fossil fuel exploration and development.
Health impacts and their costs
The subsidies the government provides to the fossil fuel industry are huge. According to an International Monetary Fund (IMF) report released in 2023, taxpayers in Australia shell out $65 billion per year or, fully 2.5% of GDP. The IMF included in its calculations implicit costs arising from health impacts – which, of course, the polluters never pay.
Globally, the IMF report states there are 4.5 million people dying prematurely each year from air pollution. In Australia, according to Kate Wylie, a representative of Doctors for the Environment, there are eleven thousand deaths per year from traffic pollution. To put that number into context, there are about one thousand deaths per year from traffic accidents.
Doctors for the Environment Australia (DEA) claim that “fossil fuels cause hazardous air pollution, increasing morbidity and rates of asthma, heart disease, cancer, learning delays, poor pregnancy outcomes and cognitive decline”.
Direct Subsidies
In the budget year of 2023-24, fossil fuel producers received $14.5 billion in direct subsidies, an increase of 31% over the previous year. Most of these subsidies are due to the government’s Fuel Tax Credit Scheme (FTCS). This provides a subsidy for fuel costs for heavy vehicles as well as fuel used for generating electricity.
Hidden Subsidies
Less conspicuous is the provision of land and water below market rates to fossil fuel projects. The economic cost is not well known because Australian coal mines are under no obligation to make data on their water use publicly available.
Coal mining in particular consumes vast amounts of water and poses significant risks of water pollution, which can contaminate rivers and underground aquifers. This issue is especially harmful during prolonged drought periods.
According to research by the Australian Conservation Foundation (ACF), the coal industry is one of Australia’s biggest water users. Coal mining and coal fired power stations in NSW and Queensland use 383 billion litres of fresh water each year; the equivalent amount used by 5.2 million people domestically.
The market value of this water is estimated at being between A$770 million and A$2.49 billion. During droughts, domestic water use is restricted. Not so for coal mines and power generation. Even in the worst of droughts, coal mining continues unabated.
During the 2019 drought, a coal mine near Lithgow, located south of the Hunter Valley, faced severe water shortages and had to depend on water deliveries by train which supplied 725 000L per day to Centennial Coal’s Charbon and Airlie coal mines.
New Fossil Fuel Projects
Since the ousting of the Morrison Liberal government, four new coal mines have been approved with a total coal output of 55 million tonnes, producing 156 million tonnes of emissions. There are 25 new mines or expansions awaiting additional approval. If approved, the lifetime emissions from these mines of almost 13 billion tonnes would be equivalent to keeping all of Australia’s coal-fired power stations operating for an additional 93 years.
Ten new oil and gas exploration licences have also been granted, as well as approval of expanding existing oil and gas operations. This includes the construction of critical infrastructure for Chevron’s Gorgon LNG Stage 2 expansion, which is projected to produce three billion tonnes of CO2 equivalent emissions over the next 50 years.
This approval, granted by the Commonwealth Government’s offshore oil and gas regulator NOPSEMA, will facilitate LNG production at Chevron’s Gorgon project. It will result in 62 million tonnes of emissions annually, which is 16 times the emissions of Western Australia’s largest coal power station, Muja.
Also in WA, Woodside Energy has approval to continue its Scarborough Energy project to complete its Pluto LNG facility off the Pilbara coast. This was approved by the WA Labor government in 2021 and has the approval of the current federal government.
The ALP Northern Territory government has approved fracking of the Betaloo Basin. According to Petroleum Australia: “the proposed Shenandoah Exploration and Appraisal project involves drilling and fracking 15 horizontal gas wells, potentially reaching depths of 4,300m and lengths over 1,000m. It is expected to use up to 1,117ML of water for fracking and drilling, including extracting 375 ML/year from the Cambrian Limestone Aquifer. The project could release up to 1.1 million tonnes of direct greenhouse gas pollution over four years and clear 145 hectares of habitat likely to support threatened and declining species.”
The Dark Reality of Capitalist Subsidies
One only must follow the piles of money that go into the coffers of the main political parties to understand why new coal mines are still being built and why state and federal governments continue to subsidies and support the fossil fuel industry. An affiliate of Friends of the Earth, Market Forces estimates that $2 million was donated to the ALP, Liberal and National Parties in 2022.
That does not include what it considered to be “dark money” which refers to funds used to influence elections, campaigns, or policy decisions where the source of the money is not disclosed to the public. This lack of transparency allows donors to contribute large sums without revealing their identity, potentially leading to undue influence over political processes. The research conducted by Market Forces notes the true figure could be much higher. According to the Centre for Public Integrity Australian political parties declared $1.38 billion in income of unexplained origin between 1998- 2021.
Labor’s continued support of fossil fuels while rhetorically making commitments to combatting climate change should not surprise anyone. Being serious about limiting global warming requires not only investing in renewable energy, but the cessation of new fossil fuel projects.
The ALP realise global warming is having an impact on people’s consciousness, but while it seeks electoral support from the broadest layers of people possible, in government the ALP has always acted within the limits imposed on it by big business. They seek to create the most favourable conditions for the profitability of the most prosperous sections of Australian capitalism – which at this present time is dominated by mining, resources and banking interests.
The ALP has failed to “end the climate wars” and cannot end them unless it stops the largest source of global warming – the burning of fossil fuels. Its support for fossil fuels makes it a culprit for committing ecocide, which future generations will demand justice for.

Leave a Reply