Palestine: Australian Imperialist Hypocrisy and the Challenge for the Peoples

A Free Palestine rally outside Sydney Opera House on Monday night when it was lit up in Israeli colours. Photograph: Dean Lewins/AAP

Opinion by Max Lane

The Australian Prime Minister, Anthony Albanese, condemned the October 8 Palestinian offensive against apartheid Israel and supported the Israeli response with the shoddy, well-worn mantra: “Israel has the right to self-defence”. Since Albanese’s statement, he has added the call for demonstrations in solidarity with the Palestinian nation be abandoned as they would be, according to him, support for acts of “abhorrent violence”.

Statements similar to these can be heard coming from the officials of the imperialist states in north America and western Europe. The ruling classes and their politicians of the imperialist bloc of countries that continue to dominate the world militarily and economically sink deeper and deeper into the moral mire of colonial hypocrisy as every day goes by. They grant impunity to both occupation and all the multiple, individual transgressions of human rights that come with it, whether assassination of children by sniper or, as even this week, the bombing of a hospital.

The moral outlook of these ruling classes and politicians remains fundamentally colonial.  In this outlook any resistance against colonial occupation is and has always been criminal, and if using arms, terrorist. So it was during the period of the European colonial empires and so it is today in the era of neo-colonialism, of modern imperialism. And so it is with the settler colonial project of Israel.

Israel, according to PM Albanese, has the right to defend its colonial occupation against the oppressed nation’s resistance while the oppressed have no right to fight back.

This attitude is a denial of the clear fact that Israel is an occupying power, enforcing its occupation through military violence.  The record of a multitude of violent acts is well-known. In this year alone, 2023, as Peoples Despatch reported:

“Israeli violence and oppression against Palestinians have increased substantially with deadly raids becoming increasingly regular. Prior to the attacks, Israeli forces had already killed over 224 Palestinians, including 38 children, already this year. Of the total, 187 were killed in the occupied West Bank and East Jerusalem and 37 in Gaza. This figure had already surpassed the record high of 178 killings in the whole of 2022.”

The widespread occupation violence can also be seen in the 1,264 Palestinians currently being held in administrative detention without charge or trial, a two-decade high, as well as the 170 children that are currently being held in Israeli prisons.

The Israeli occupation has also meant the inhumane, torturing blockade of Gaza, carried out in collaboration with the Egyptian regime; bombings of Gaza; raids on Palestinian farms and many other acts of violence. Year by year as armed settlers start new settlements in the West Bank, more and more territory is lost to the Palestinian nation.

All this history is on the record and well-known to anybody who wishes to look closely.

Albanese and his fellow imperialist politicians throughout the imperialist countries are defenders of Israeli’s right to conquest, occupation, terror and murder.

The West’s imperialism has a zillion crimes in its history. The now 75-year long occupation of Palestine, funded, equipped and diplomatically supported by the U.S., the E.U. and Australia, is one of the greatest ongoing crimes.

The resistance of the Palestinian people is one of the greatest examples of a heroic struggle for liberation.

Some people of a liberal political outlook may plead that all sides should conform to the legalities and that both sides can be condemned for illegalities, for example when civilians are harmed. Given the 75 years of occupation and resistance, legality was long abandoned by the occupier and its foreign funders.  Israeli settlers and others, bear arms and hold demonstrations shouting “Kill the Arabs”. Observers from outside, and certainly myself, should not dare to try to evaluate the rights and wrongs of the tactics of those resisting an occupation under these conditions.

Actually, most people who will read this essay, are aware already of all points I have made above.

The challenge for the peoples of the world, and the people of Australia, starting with those of a democratic outlook, is what to do to help end this situation, bleeding agonisingly now for 75 years.

In Palestine itself the key necessary victory is the defeat of Israel’s military occupation, of Israel’s military domination. Until this at least starts to happens, there can be no real steps towards solutions. And what may be the solutions? Any accommodation the Palestinian nation wishes to make – if any at all – to the uninvited migrant-occupiers and their descendants is up to it to decide. But nothing can happen until Israel’s capacity to coerce is broken.

Palestinian military resistance, and perhaps resistance from its allies, will be one very key determinant factor. Apart from imposing costs on Israel, it is an essential part of the Palestinian nation’s manifestation of its will to resist, despite the occupier’s violence.

The human costs of occupation and resistance of this type are horrific. The more quickly it ends the better. The only way that Israeli military power can be broken sooner is if imperialist states’ support for Israel ends. This, in turn, depends on the strength of organised and mobilised public support for Palestine in the imperialist countries which demands withdrawal of budgetary and military aid for Israel.  Israel is the largest cumulative recipient of US aid since World War 2. According to the US Congressional Research Service:

To date, the United States has provided Israel $158 billion (current, or noninflation-adjusted, dollars) in bilateral assistance and missile defense funding. At present, almost all U.S. bilateral aid to Israel is in the form of military assistance; from 1971 to 2007, Israel also received significant economic assistance.

At the moment the US is providing $3 billion dollars per year. Support from Western European countries is also substantial, while their aid to Palestine is less and almost impossible to receive and use because of Israeli embargos and blockades.. Following the recent military increased resistance to the Israeli occupation, a dispute has arisen among EU countries as to whether EU aid to Palestine should be frozen.

The Israeli occupation can only continue while the U.S. and other western imperialist countries fund the occupation. It is also this massive US support for Israel that works at the same time as intense pressure on the Arab world’s states to limit their concrete support for the Palestinian struggles.

Australia does not provide military aid to Israel but does have defence agreements and investments in Israel. As at November 2022, 19 Israeli companies were listed on the Australian Stock Exchange (ASX), making Israel the equal-third largest source of foreign company listings.

However, Australia supports the “two state solution” while remaining silent on the reality of the war of occupation, as is manifested in Albanese and others’ recent statements.

We return to the question of what can be done to end Australian support for apartheid Israel’s war of occupation. Of course, it goes without saying that wherever possible people concerned about this should attend or support the demonstrations in solidarity with the struggle for a Free Palestine. The Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions campaign could also be strengthened. But these have been occurring for decades without really substantially growing, even though – perhaps – a general sentiment in sympathy with the Palestinians has grown as Israel’s violent lust for expanding the occupation has become more visible.

To defeat the outlook manifested by Albanese and co. requires an all-out campaign to spread and deepen internationalist and humanist consciousness among the Australian people, the Australian working class. This in particular is a task that trade unionists, progressives and socialists and all radical youth must prioritise. There can be no such thing as an isolationist, let alone chauvinist, socialist heart.

Solidarity with the Palestinian people and nation is solidarity with all the exploited peoples of the Global South. Defeat of the occupation will be a victory for all.

If we are able to then all join the coming protests! But let’s also think through how to build solidarity even stronger and more effective.

Author

Leave a Reply